Moneyball’s Impact | The Golden Sombrero Baseball Blog | MLB, Fantasy, College & High School Baseball News

Moneyball’s Impact

With Moneyball opening this weekend nationwide, I have received several questions from friends and classmates about the movie since the cast is pretty loaded and the reviews so noteworthy.  I calmly have explained to them that Moneyball is the most important piece of literature ever created.  They quite obviously are skeptical and find such a claim laughable.  This is Texas after all and I do live across the highway from SMU.  I do firmly believe, though, that no book could have possibly influenced my life more profoundly than Moneyball did and continues to do.

I purchased Moneyball for my father as a Father’s Day gift shortly after it was released.  I saw a book with a baseball on the cover that allegedly was about the economical side of the game.  It sounded perfect for my dad who both loves baseball and reads the Wall Street Journal daily.  He enjoyed it, but I think he resented it too and continues to do so somewhat today.  When he was done with it, I read it.  I couldn’t put it down.  I was in high school and the books we read for school were what most would probably call classics.  I thought they were exceedingly boring and for the most part, I just read Cliff’s Notes.  Moneyball was quite possibly the first book I ever loved.  I think I understood immediately that my father and I would never see the game the same way again, and because of it I’m not sure I really began growing up and being my own person until I read it.

Moneyball represents in certain ways the game’s steps into adulthood as well.  The way the scouting side of the game is represented in the book reminds me of a screaming child who refuses to listen to reason and instead throws a tantrum.  This is obviously a dramatized version of the way the situation during the early 2000s actually was, but I did not know any better at the time and I doubt many did.  Nevertheless, Moneyball identified that the game had evolved and did so by pinpointing the exact time that outsiders took notice.

I have read Moneyball several times since then, and Whitney even agreed to read it to me after I graduated from Grinnell while we drove back to New Mexico from Iowa, stopping along the way for a buddy and teammate’s wedding.

Moneyball showed the baseball community and even those on the fringes of it that baseball players don’t have to look like Griffey or A-Rod.  They can look like Pedroia.  He won an MVP and might have gone undrafted without smart folks pointing out that “the good face” is a luxury with no bearing on whether or not someone can ball.  Balling is about finding out how to maximize every single attribute each of us has.  It’s not just the five tools and it for damn sure isn’t about being tall and lean.  It’s about barreling up, playing clean, and taking a walk if it’s offered.  More than any of that, though, it’s about understanding what makes a real, honest to God winner on the diamond and away from it.

The book opened the door to front offices and even the dugout to intellectual types who may not have signed a professional contract or even touched the diamond in an NCAA-sanctioned game.  Beyond that, though, it encouraged and maybe even forced baseball types to listen to those who had not been educated within baseball culture.  The revolution that Moneyball identified and displayed to the masses aided (maybe more so than anything else) us in realizing that there existed valuable and measurable attributes going virtually unnoticed by those who were paid to find them.

It’s not so much that Moneyball defined the revolution.  It is more that it provided it with names, faces, and a narrative.  It supplied the emotion and passion that were felt by so many as we began to understand what the implications of these new metrics really were.  The way we evaluate everything has changed since then.  For everyone at The Sombrero, its implications extend far beyond the diamond.  Moneyball is about an ideology based in critical and objective evaluation of data used to guide our decisions and our emotions.  Yeah, it taught me to take a walk, but it also taught me why I should.  It taught us that as baseball players, fans, men, friends, and whatever else we might call ourselves, we have never learned enough.  There is always ground to be gained and always a reason to know more than we do today.  Moneyball meant that the game had a future to me.  I would not be writing any of these words without what Michael Lewis and Billy Beane gave us.


  1. Rick B. says:

    Well said D. I always referred to the kids that shined at the showcases and sucked during the actual games as show ponies. This book helped give confidence to a soft tossing right-hander who tried to win with control, movement, and guile. It also helped open the minds of coaches (college and pro) to a certain extent and allowed a foot in the door for a short, or less athletic player.

  2. Flips says:

    Very well said Barf. I am not sure that the majority of the millions who see this movie will truly understand and appreciate it for what it is. The way it changed the game is a mere byproduct of someone willing to think outside of the box.